Official "Neither Here Nor There" Episode Rating

[bookworm2342]

Once you've seen the episode, feel free to vote/comment on your rating for episode 4.01 "Neither Here Nor There".

Please keep comments in this thread related to how you would score this episode. Feel free to post your reviews, thoughts, deeper feelings towards this episode in the central discussion thread - this way we can keep things organized.

[Lij]

It might have just been a case of FRINGE-deprivation, but I gave it a 10!

But it was classic FRINGE.

[trishy81]

Fantastic episode. And we even got to see Peter....twice!

[vesh1717]

I gave it a 6. Wasn't bad, but wasn't good either. Too much change for me, even though I expected it. lol The longer Peter is away the more I will be annoyed too.

[Omniscient_Jay]

After some thought, I've decided to give it an 8.

It was excellent; it's only real detractor was that it was burdened with the exposition that the revised timelines required, so it left me wanting more (which I suppose means that it succeeded ).

I am most intrigued by September's change of heart regarding Peter. It shall be interesting to see the fallout of this act (and I totally love that the Observers are poised have a prominent role this season).

Seven days...

[fury161]

It definitely left me wanting more, the time went by so fast.

[fragaria x phile]

a few kinks to work out, but it's a start

[theNomadz]

6/10 for me, I thought it was pretty weak, not back with a bang but a whimper.

[Mutsie]

9/10 Definitely! I really loved the way they created "The Bridge" !PETER! created and the facts -changes & the bitch-around of the 2 Olivia's when they were talking {LOL} & yeah Peter!!!!

[Olive_Dunham]

I gave it an 8. Very good episode.
Of course it's just the beginning and it was really exciting but it left me with the feeling that something's missing (yeah it's not just Peter, though I miss him to death )
It was like too much change but no answers...yet!
It kept me on the edge of my seat, indeed, and I'm still there, like, I expected some resolution of some kind, but I understand that everything was pretty different and it's impossible to sort of try to explain why or how, all in one episode, when there's also a plot going on...
I remember last year, when I watched 'Olivia', I had weird feelings regarding the episode, Olivia believing she was her alternate, her being trapped there, the 'interdimensional crack(?)' sealed with Amber...I felt a little like 'Ok this is gonna be odd', so I guess it's me this time, that's different. For example last year we kinda knew the other side, there was Walternate and the shapeshifters and zeppelins, Amber, Lincoln and Walter and Broyles, so really the only q's were how is Olivia gonna get out of there? and will Peter realize she's not her, I think we started the season wondering that, now it's like a whole new beginning and many things are different, and I'm too anxious and want to figure everything out right away...lol yeah it's not the episode, it's me so I'll stop rambling...

Anyway, it was a kick-ass start, and really well handled too, so there you go, a very good episode!

And the best is yet to come!