First peter was stupid for not realizing the Olivia he came back for wasn't his Olivia but now Peter is stupid for what exactly for thinking with his heart and not his "male" impluses? For being confused and wanting to figure things out before he makes a big mistake for being with an Olivia who just happens to have BlueOlivia's memories?

People are so interested in proving Peter wrong but maybe Peter is right?

Either way, peter can never win.