I gave it a 9. I loved it! And we're getting to see that Peter is not perfect. He can be a jerk. I actually like that they're doing this. Everyone is terribly flawed on this show. Ahhh...
I am surprised at all the "Debbie Downers" about this episode. These last 2 are actually on my fave episodes list. But to each their own.
I was matched up with this guy two weeks ago and we were talking about shows. He can't stand Fringe. Thinks it's boring and the plot is weak. You know what happened with him
Thanks Julipy for Avitar. Love your Walstrid art <3
5 from me. I just didn't enjoy it. Probably had something to do with the Olivia focus (not the next episode though - WOO!), and a lot to do with the stupid characterisation of Peter in this episode that I still can't wrap my head around. No character growth from either of them, it seems, and I was bored.
Would have been a six but I still can't sort out my feelings towards that terrifying/hilarious dancing corpse scene that I know I'll be dreaming about tonight. Thank you Fringe!
9...amazing...heartbreaking...creepy when the guy used the ballerina as a doll...great performances...cliffhanger at the end...THE OBSERVER IS FINALLY BACK...walter funny scenes...astrid rocks btw...great episode in a few words...now merry-fringeless-Christmas
I gave it a 9 but having rewatched it 2 more times I feel I was hasty in my judgement. It was definitely one of the best acted and written episode ever, not only on Fringe but also on TV. Maybe not a cup of tea for someone who watches Fringe mostly for action and Sci-fi mythology but for me - definitely a 10!
Very good episode!
I gave it a 9
That heart thing, absolutely fantastic...
I went with a 9, I'm loving it so much right now its like every episode is getting better and better, its matured so much from its original X-files clone format into the best show on TV. I still rank the 'Peter' episode as the shows finest moment but the last couple arn't far behind that in quality.
This was definitely my favorite episode ever.
banner & avatar by me / follow me on tumblr
My P/O fanvideos: Keep Breathing, Cosmic Love, Never Gonna Leave Me, and Not Sure Yet
I gave it a solid 10. This episode hurt! This episode made me cry! That's pretty good for a monster of the week epi, no?
(Just an observation):
For a woman who doesn't talk much about her feelings, Olivia sure had a lot to say. For a guy who talks so much and so fast, Peter sure had little to say.
Can't wait for FRIDAY, January 21st !!!!
I love aftermath moments/episodes. The payback possible from a single line or gesture or reaction can summate a character's experience with a recent dramatic event so poignantly.
This episode had two. One for Olivia - the MIT t-shirt in the washer. One for Peter - the two empty lawn chairs. Brilliant. Just brilliant.
I give it a 9.
Last edited by OldDarth; 01-21-2011 at 12:38 AM.
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks