1 for babygate.
10 - Best Fringe Episode EVER!!
9 - Absolutely Amazing
8 - Very Good Episode
7 - Good Episode
6 - Just Okay
5 - MEH
4 - Poor Episode
3 - Very Poor Episode
2 - OMG, That Was Terrible!!
1 - Worst Fringe Episode EVER!!
Once you've seen the episode, feel free to vote/comment on your rating for episode 3.13 "Immortality".
Please keep comments in this thread related to how you would score this episode. Feel free to post your reviews, thoughts, deeper feelings towards this episode in the central discussion thread - this way we can keep things organized.
1 for babygate.
Despite my hatred of the ending, the episode itself was fine. It would've been better had I been emotionally invested in the characters, but overall it wasn't terrible. I did enjoy the AltCharlie-FauxLivia interactions, as well as the Lincoln-FauxLivia interactions. My rating is 6, because of the ending and the fact that overall I didn't care if FauxLivia lived or died.
I gave it a 9! It lost a point because of the. And the ending worked for me. I love Altlivia and Olivia, and can't wait until next week. And yeah, I liked the last five minutes the best.
I knew the ending was coming, so that only effects the score slightly. I just hated the episode. A monster of the week episode where I didn't care if the monsters killed Fauxlivia or everyone over there. My least favorite episode in three seasons. 1.
I gave it 2, the lowest I have ever rated a Fringe episode. The only good things include Fauxlivia and Charlie scenes and that is it.
I gave it an 8... because I loved this episode - at least until Altlivia's pregnancy was revealed.
But somehow, I have faith in the writers. I don't know why and I don't even know why I don't hate this episode. Maybe because it's 4.50 am here in Germany and I'm too tired to freak out...
I gave it an 8. I'm upset about babygate, of course, but I liked the way they introduced it. I think that it was the best possible way to do the whole pregnancy thing. I also liked how we got to see Lincoln and Fauxlivia's relationship with one another, and Fauxlivia and Charlie. I really enjoyed seeing Over there. I think the episode itself (disregarding the pregnancy thing) was really good. It was a little confusing, but it was interesting. And Walter saying he was going to be a grandfather almost made it worth it that Fauxlivia is pregnant (I'm just trying to be positive)
I gave it an 8. Enjoyed the episode overall, especially scenes that included alt-Charlie and Lincoln. No need to freak out about the pregnancy; we all knew it was coming.
The reveal was obvious, so I'm not real shocked or anything (though I remain somewhat disappointed that they chose this route after all).
The actual episode was alright, I suppose. The case itself was not that intriguing (although the entirety of the sheep population being wiped out was pretty cool). The (alt)character moments were strong, as per usual; I particularly enjoyed the humourous banter between Altlivia/Frank and and Altlivia/Charlie.
Lincoln's secret thing was kind of lame, as was the end reveal and the fact that they didn't really show how Broyles and his disappearance had affected the Division other than passing mentions and whatnot.
I guess I'll give it a 6 (though technically a 6.5).